I've been a fan of Women's Basketball for some time now. I can recall the early teams of Head Coach Vivian Stringer at the University of Iowa. They were good, athletic and tough. But those were the early days. Even though I watched the Hawkeyes, I didn't have the same buy into the game that I do today. Caitlin Clark no doubt had a big part of that notion. Her play took the game into another part of the sports stratosphere.
![]() |
| We have a major issue in Women's Basketball |
What also came along with this greater interest was the better athletes and many more "good" teams. Competition was full screen. And viewership jumped immensely. A little over two years ago, during Iowa's run to two straight National Championship Finals we began seeing Clark harassed, hand checked, held and knocked down. At first, she took it. Then after a while, she began fighting back. And the battle was on.
In the 2023 South Carolina-Iowa title game the referees were severely scrutinized for the job they performed. Some were critical of the fact three women officiated the game, others said their race was a factor. And then perhaps the biggest was criticism was that they were inexperienced.
Fast forward a couple of basketball seasons and were still seeing the same issues. It makes one wonder why the NCAA hasn't stepped in and asked more of their referees. Do they need further training? Do they need to have a lessened workload, so they are fresh? Are the qualifications they need to have been reached? I have no answer to those questions. But I do know this. It's the old axiom..."If you keep doing the same thing, you'll keep getting the same results"-Albert Einstein.
A recent NCAA Tournament game featuring Notre Dame and TCU brought the same old mindset. TCU was extremely physical and won 71-62. The internet showed fan's immediate thoughts:
"Social media, as expected, blew up. Complaints mounting against officiating have been a common theme this year in the women's tournament. But to see it happen against some of the biggest pairs in the game? Obviously, fans had their piece to say. The NCAA community did not react well to the matchup's outcome. 'This Notre Dame-TCU game is one of the worst officiated games in women's college basketball history. Absolutely painful to watch. This officiating crew should never work another game'. One fan said on X, holding nothing back against the game officials. This was a relatively common sentiment amongst supporters. Refs are absolutely screwing Notre Dame against TCU".
So, what is being asked of referees?
ROLE AND RESPONSIBILTY
Referees are the authority figures on the court, tasked with making calls on fouls, violations, and other in-game decisions. They play a crucial role in maintaining order and ensuring the game is played according to the rules
FAIRNESS AND CONSISTENCY
Referees are expected to make unbiased decisions, treating all players equally regardless of their race, nationality, gender, sexual orientation, or religion. Thet receive specific education and training to apply the laws of the game consistently and fairly.
Fairly? Perhaps you'll recall an NCAA Tourney game last year when at half-time an official was replaced because she had a high graduate degree from one of the teams that was playing. How was that not known?
The answer to this mess will not be a simple one. The words below, sadly, offer what most likely will happen:
The Athletic conducted more than 50 interviews with NCAA sources, administrators, coaches, players, commissioners and more than a dozen Division I current and former women’s basketball officials, many of whom requested anonymity to speak freely. Stakeholders within the sport painted a bleak picture: Currently, three people control more than 75 percent of the regular season officiating jobs; officiating styles are inconsistent across conferences; the system lacks a formal developmental framework and security for officials; and there has been limited transparency on almost every level.
“This is a five-to-10-year fix,” said one high-ranking administrator. “And we’re nowhere close to starting that.”
As we head to the last weekend of both the men's and women's title runs be aware of a part of the sport that absolutely sucks. Bad refereeing. I recall a quote from an old basketball coach friend of mine. "The best games are the ones you didn't notice the officials".
If only we could be so lucky.....





