I've held no secrets that I am a fan of the Chicago White Sox. During the many years that I have been, I've seen a multitude of players come in go. Some I'm glad to see gone, others I like in Chicago and others I wish we had back. One of those players, in my mind, is right-handed pitcher Brandon McCarthy.
McCarthy was a jewel in the White Sox organization. Despite being drafted in the 17th round in 2002, he rose through the minor league chain at break neck speed. He led the minor leagues in strikeouts in 2004. He was well thought of, let's put it that way. Most Sox fans was a top of the line starter on the horizon. But Chicago General Manager Ken Williams had other ideas. Twelve big league starts were enough to convince Williams that he'd trade McCarthy. On December 23, 2006, Brandon was traded along with David Paisano to the Texas Rangers for John Danks, Nick Masset and Jake Rasner. I was bummed the White Sox made the trade. John Danks has been an up and down hurler since coming over from Texas. I'm not sure who really got the best of that trade, probably a wash.
Since the deal in 2006, it has been a struggle for the 6 foot 7 inch righthander. He suffered from a stress fracture in his shoulder blade and had inflammation in the the right elbow. The Rangers finally said good-bye. In 2010, he signed as a free agent with the Oakland Athletics. For the last two seasons, McCarthy has seen his game come back. In 2011 he led the American League in FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching) and this year he was leading Oakland in strikeouts. Then came a game last week against division rival, the Los Angeles Angels. Here is the media story of the night:
"Athletics pitcher Brandon McCarthy left in the fourth inning of Wednesday's 7-1 loss to the L.A. Angles after Erick Aybar's hard line drive ricocheted off the right-hander's head. McCarthy was taken to Alta Bates Summit Medical Center in Oakland as a precaution, and the team said doctors wanted him to stay overnight for further observation. McCarthy had almost no time react when Aybar lined his 91-mph cutter back up the middle. The ball bounced off the right side of McCarthy's head, knocking him down. He also landed on his head on the infield grass".
 |
Walking off???? are you kidding me? |
Now for the confusing part. After Oakland trainers attended to McCarthy, they let him sit up and ultimately walk off the field under his own power. The picture above depicts this. Then after reaching the hospital, he subsequently underwent surgery for two hours to relieve cranial pressure after CT scans revealed he had suffered an epidural hemmorhage, a brain contusion and a skull fracture. So, I ask you this....WHY? Why would any medical staff allow McCarthy to walk off that field? If someone doesn't do some investigation as to why he wasn't taken off on a stretcher, than we have serious issues with player safety. As if we don't already....
First reports were that he was fighting for his life and he was in intensive care. Six days later, McCarthy is still in the hospital recovering Saturday, he put out some twitter comments to show he was improving health-wise. :
"The good news in all of this, is that I set up my fantasy lineups beforehand. So there shall be no excuses at this point"...and he also made a funny reference to how "crazy" he is for the children's pain medication he gets-and "can't believe they give it to kids".
The call for reform? Perhaps Rick Telander of the Chicago Sun-Times does a good job of summing it up:
"In my opinion, being a pitcher and following through on a big-league pitch-getting into that helpless position in which the body has just completed a violent act with maximum effort and is off-balance and defenseless, while a man stands 20 yards away with a club, swinging at a rock-hard ball-is about the scariest position an athlete can be in. I'd put it up there with a quarterback getting blitzed from the blind side, a NASCAR driver starting a spin, a cyclist hitting an oil slick. It's interesting that all those other athletes wear helmet. Maybe "interesting" isn't the word".
Telander forgot hockey. How about standing in front of a goal and taking a puck directly at your head at 100 mph. That's interesting!
I remember a number of years ago when hockey goalies didn't wear masks and the players were without helmets. Then change began. Slowly goalies began donning the "mask" There was a goalie from the Minnesota North Stars by the name of Gump Worsley who hung to the lack of facial protection for as long as he could. And that was inspite of a metal plate in his head from an accident years prior that rendered him near death.
But back to baseball. It's time for reform.at all levels. And throw in softball as well. Athletes are too big, too strong, pitchers throw too fast and the bats that are made now are a virtual weapon at hand.
Brandon McCarthy might be offering twitter funnies of his death escape, but you can bet deep down, he's said more than one prayer that he's thankful he's alive. Alive and able to be with his family. And looking at a baseball career that might be long gone.
UPDATE: 9/11/12 AT 8:12 A.M.
McCarrthy took a few steps on Monday at the hospital and is progressing in his recovery.
UPDATE TO UPDATE: 9/11/12 AT 5:07 P.M.
McCarthy was discharged from the hospital. He is to remain in the Bay Area for the next 3 weeks.
Thanks for reading,
John